Historical article: Originally published May 10, 2011 on Customer Service Numbers Blog. Restored and expanded November 17, 2026.
Jell-O’s “Pudding Face” commercial turned the pleasure of eating pudding into an enormous, unmistakable smile. Our original May 2011 post found that expression creepy and questioned the joke about a father who could not hide what he had done.
What was the Pudding Face joke?
The premise was simple: the father’s face gives him away. Rather than an ordinary satisfied smile, the commercial uses an exaggerated grin as the visual punch line. Our original article interpreted it as another example of a parent being caught in a lie over dessert.
“Creepy” was our editorial reaction to that expression, not a claim about the pudding itself. A viewer who enjoyed the absurdity could see a broad visual joke where another saw an unsettling face.
A smile that became a wider campaign
Pudding Face also appeared beyond the television spot. The One Club’s campaign record describes a Jell-O Mood Meter created by CP+B that tracked smiling and frowning emoticons on Twitter. The smiling-face concept connected the product to the idea of cheering people up.
That broader campaign helps explain the oversized grin, but it does not settle whether the television execution worked for an individual viewer.
Find Pudding Face on YouTube
Open “New Jell-O Pudding Face Commercial” on YouTube. This third-party upload is credited to TOKENFATK1D. It is a different upload from the one linked in our original article; playback availability may change.
What did you think of it?
Did the exaggerated smile make you laugh, or did it distract from the dessert? Our original criticism centered on the face and the portrayal of the father, rather than on a shopping or product complaint.
For another Jell-O advertising discussion from the same year, see the Choco Beast monster commercial. For product assistance, use our Kraft customer service guide.
